How Do You Measure Executive Fit? Against the Role as It Exists Today

Sometimes the job description a company brings to a search is ten years old. Fernando Espinosa, CEO of Top Notch Finders, said exactly that on Good Business San Diego, and it is where measuring executive fit begins: with the role as it exists today, not the role as it was once written.

Watch the full interview https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZCG9KEakfhY

What our searches show

Eighty percent of our searches are confidential replacements. Someone is performing the job today, and the company needs a different person in it. Fernando gave three reasons on the show: the incumbent stopped learning, the incumbent does not want to integrate the new technologies or systems the company is moving to, or the business needs to reach its next level.

Read those three again. None of them says the person was unqualified when they were hired. In each case the role moved and the person did not. That is why a job description written at the time of the last hire is a poor guide to the next one.

Retention is the other half of the evidence. Our executive placements hold at 89 percent at 24 months [VERIFY: Fernando, confirm the figure, the sample and the period it covers]. Fernando’s explanation was direct: when selection is done with real due diligence and aimed at the right organization, the likelihood of keeping the person is high. He also pointed out how hard the job is for CEOs and VPs to perform, and that turnover costs a company a great deal.

Why a resume cannot measure fit

A resume records what a person did in a past role at a past company. Fit is a relationship between a person and one specific organization, right now. Fernando put it this way: not every person can be “the right person for every company,” only for the right organization.

That is why screening a stack of resumes turns into a blur. Candidates with similar histories look identical on paper, and the paper cannot show which of them suits this company’s context. The measurement has to come from the other side of the table.

How we measure it: the debrief with decision-makers

Before we screen anyone, we debrief the decision-makers. Fernando called this a very critical component of finding the right person for any job. The debrief goes well beyond the job description:

  • Context
  • Metrics
  • Expectations
  • Emotional intelligence
  • Cultural intelligence
  • Artificial intelligence

Together, he said, these factors give the recipe for the right person for each company.

The debrief produces a description of the role as it exists today, in the words of the people who will work with the hire. That is the yardstick. Every candidate is measured against it. A candidate who does not fit this company is not necessarily a weak candidate. They may be the right candidate for a different one.

What this means if you are hiring

Before you read a single resume:

  • Hold the debrief with the decision-makers. Do not start from the old job description.
  • Treat the existing description as a draft and ask what has changed since it was written.
  • If you are replacing someone, ask what the role now needs that the person leaving did not provide.
  • Write down the metrics before the first interview, so every candidate is judged against the same thing.
  • Be honest about the hard parts of the role. Fernando noted that sharing only the good parts and not the bad parts is very difficult, and that the answer is consistency in values and treating everyone with respect and honesty. A candidate who hears the whole picture can judge their own fit.

Hire for the role you have today

Fernando’s closing advice on the show applies to hiring as much as to running a business: be consistent with your principles, have a purpose, and make sure what sets you apart is not only your technology, your pricing or your marketing. It is who you are, and whether you walk the talk.

We are a boutique firm, and the standard Fernando sets is that we run each search as if it were our own business. Measuring fit against the role as it exists today is how we do that.

If you are planning an executive search in San Diego or Baja California, lets connect.